It’s safe to say that I’ve been through all liquid liners. There is a dedicated drawer (the eye liner grave) in my vanity for them. After a recent trip to Urban Outfitters of all places, I discovered Ardency Inn’s Modster liner so I gave it a go. My issue with other liners is that it’s not thick enough and runs into the crease of my eyelid. Monster is honestly the only one I’ve found that stays all day without running and gives me that dark, matt liner look that I love. The flocked applicator gives you ultimate control for smooth glide application. My trick to creating the shape? Close your eye and follow the natural curve up and out to your desired end point. From there, go back and fill in the rest.